I have had both. I had a 2003 1800 Goldwing, I now have a 2009 Venture. In the past I have had 22 new metric bikes, two were Voyagers, two were Nomads, and two were concourses... E-nuff said ! The Goldwing to me was over rated by far, unless you like riding a sopha down the highway. It's not a motorcycle, it's a convertable minus two wheels. Get the Venture, I can tell you, you will love the best of both worlds!