An interesting review for sure. My demo experience was a bit different. I'm not sure how tall the reviewer is in that video but at 5'9" with a 28" inseam the Star Venture fit me like a glove. I could easily flat foot the bike, and did not feel the bike was "wide" at all. I'm thinking someone with a longer inseam and therefore higher knees might have to straddle the tank a lot more than I did. I don't remember where my knees were in relation to the tank when I drove the Star Venture but I definitely felt it was now wide. Now the 2002 Goldwing I had, that was a wide bike. With my feet up on highway pegs, I felt like I was straddling the grand canyon. Even though on paper the Wing only has a 1.5" higher seat height compared to the SV (29.1" vs. 27.4), it felt like more like 3-4" from what I remember because the wing was so wide. I could bend my knees and flat foot the SV whereas on the wing I had to be on tip toes after sliding far forward on the seat. The seat and the seating position of the SV was immediately comfortable to me on the short ride I took.
My demo ride was on a sunny 75 degree day, and I could feel no heat coming of the engine. Its good to know that sitting in traffic in the 96 degree Florida heat how much the engine/tank throws a huge amount of heat. Although I've never sat in traffic on a sunny 96 degree day on even liquid a cooled bike and not feel like I was getting baked.
I agree with the reviewer about the power. I too was expecting more power based on the size of the engine and all the hoopla about it in the Yamaha videos. I also was kinda shocked by the really low RPM limiter. However the reviewer kept mentioning the FJR1300 and compared to an FJR most anything short of a full out liter sport bike is going to feel slow. Compared to my vStar 1300 the SV had a bit more grunt. Still, it really does seem like it should get moving faster.
My other opinions on the SV: Love the big floorboards, didn't miss the heal shifter and would not add it if I got one (its an option) allowing more freedom to move around my left foot. I also loved the suspension. My demo was 2-up with my wife (neither of us being lightweights) on the back and the SV absorbed bumps like a champ, even better than the Goldwing which has a very harsh front end due to its anti-dive implementation. Unlike the reviewer I didn't feel like the bike was very top heavy at slow speeds even 2-up, and I didn't feel the handlebars were strange at all like he did. Slow speed handling was actually a lot better than I expected. The wind deflectors under the mirrors made a huge difference on the amount of wind hitting the driver and passenger as did the windshield when raised and lowered.
Now all of my opinions are based on a 20 minute demo ride which included some stop and go in traffic, some riding at 40-45mph on some back roads, and about 2 miles on a highway on which we got up to 60mph.
As far as the passenger seat goes, my wife gave it the double thumbs up. We've test ridden Victory's, HD, BMW's and more. The SV was the only bike that had passenger accommodations comparable to the Goldwing which is the gold standard according to my wife.
John